Franchisor Franchisee Litigation: Perception versus Reality

Published on April 04, 2016

Share Tweet Share

When considering a franchise opportunity, one of the most important items, a prospective franchisee should review is the disclosed litigation between a franchisor and its franchisees. Presented in Item 3 of the Franchise Disclosure Document, this component of the due diligence process has been recommended by franchise attorneys and franchise industry professionals for countless years. There is little doubt that the amount and type of litigation a franchisor disclosed in their FDD can provide insight into the state and quality of franchise relations in a franchise system. However, what it doesn’t reveal is the amount of litigation that’s avoided due to a franchisor and franchisee amicably resolving their differences.

Under the amended FTC Franchise Rule, certain suits falling into four broad categories must be disclosed in Item 3: pending lawsuits, lawsuits involving the franchise relationship, prior lawsuits, and current government injunctive or restrictive actions. These include arbitrations. When analyzing franchise system litigation at FranchiseGrade.com, we compute an index that compares the amount of litigation to the number of franchisee outlets. This will address the fact that large systems are more apt to have more litigation cases than smaller systems and that any litigation must be disclosed for a period of ten years.

Analysis

An analysis of the FranchiseGrade.com database of 2,500 FDD’s indicated the following amount of litigation ranked by percent of franchise systems with disclosed cases. In spite of certain perceptions regarding franchise industry litigation, the data indicates that 92% of franchise systems disclose 0-3 litigation cases brought against franchisees, while 85% of systems disclose 0-3 cases brought against franchisors. In an ideal business world, there be no litigation, however, in reality considering the size and number of franchises in the U.S. these statistics portray a more positive relationship between franchisors and their franchisees than some might perceive to be the case. Although the measure of franchise relations consists of more than one variable this data provides an interesting overview of litigation between the parties.

The following table presents the percent of disclosed litigation by franchise systems by number of cases:

  Franchisor Litigation vs. Franchisee Franchisee Litigation vs. Franchisor
Cases Disclosed Percent of Franchise Systems Percent of Franchise Systems
0 75% 57%
1-3 17% 28%
4-9 4% 8.2%
10-25 2.3% 4.5%
26 + 1.7% 2.3%
  92% of Franchisors had 3 or less lawsuits 85% of Franchisees had 3 or less lawsuits

It’s important that prospective franchisees include a review of disclosed litigation as an important component of their due diligence process. However, the above data reveals that a preponderance of franchise systems operate with little or no litigation. This should cause the outliers that disclose more litigation to receive added scrutiny.

Written by FranchiseGrade.com Team


Thinking about buying a franchise?
Not sure how much can you afford?

Fill out our Franchise Affordability Calculator




Related Articles

New York Times Investigates Subways Abuse of Franchisees

New York Times investigation into the use of questionable practices by one its Franchise Development Agents that culminated in the agent acquiring two of a franchisees Subway stores.

Read More

The Fall of A Giant – Are Subway’s Healthiest Days Behind Them?

Read More

What Sub-Franchising Really Means

Sub-franchising is frequently confused with other franchise models, including area developers, master franchisors, regional developers.

Read More

Maximize Market Penetration and Branding with Multi-Unit Franchisees

Multi-unit franchising grows in popularity, in the Quick Serve Restaurant sector, this model continues to expand into other franchise sectors in popularity.

Read More

The Top 10 Franchise Grade Facts & Figures From 2017

Detailed studies on emerging franchise success rates, errors in Item 20 disclosure and sector performance, Franchise Grade’s reports help you.

Read More

A Road Block to Franchise Growth is Right Under Your Nose

New franchise growth is the top priority for emerging franchise brands. Many of these franchises have an obstacle on the road to more franchise locations.

Read More

Franchisors Need to Avoid Wasting Their Franchisee Leads

When franchisors strategize their system growth, the major focus is placed on the amount and quality of their franchisee leads.

Read More